The Growth Brief · October 27, 2026

AI Visibility Audits Only Give 2% of the Score to the Place Buyers Go Next

AI assistants send a sliver of the traffic Google does, yet 16% of shoppers now start product searches in ChatGPT, and the gap between those two facts is where the work is.

Rand Fishkin asked last week whether AI visibility is a marketing boondoggle, and the three studies he rounded up make a strong case that it’s at least oversold. Marie Haynes looked at 12 months of GA4 data from 100 websites and found Google organic drove 27 times more conversions than every LLM combined. SEOWorks studied 95 sites over 12 months and found organic search sent 39 times more traffic than AI assistants. Kevin Indig went looking for the indirect effect, the branded searches and direct visits AI supposedly drives, and couldn’t detect it yet in his 12-site sample. Fishkin’s conclusion is to treat AI as a brand channel, closer to a billboard, and measure it that way.

I agree with that conclusion, and I think the traffic numbers point somewhere more useful than “spend less.” Digiday rounded up shopper surveys the same week: Feedvisor found 16% of shoppers start product searches on ChatGPT, while only 9% go there to buy. PartnerCentric asked what people do after an AI suggests something, and 33% check reviews, 22.3% compare prices, 18.8% search Amazon or another retailer, and 14.8% visit the brand’s website.

So if AI is shaping the shortlist, why doesn’t it show up in anyone’s referral report? My read is that the shopper takes the recommendation somewhere else to check it, so the visit that finally converts comes from a review site, a retailer, or a Google search, and your analytics credits it to someone other than ChatGPT. Those are consumer surveys, but I’d bet B2B buyers do the same thing with G2, a peer, or a Reddit thread.

Now look at what most AI visibility audits measure. Andy Crestodina at Orbit Media reviewed 100 free audits and averaged the scoring across 14 tools: technical architecture got 46% of the weight, content and structure 33%, what the AI answers say 19%, and everything off your website, where reviews and retailer listings live, 2%. Orbit’s own site scored anywhere from 28 to 100 depending on the tool. The audits spend almost all their attention on the brand’s website, the stop 14.8% of PartnerCentric’s shoppers made, and almost none on the reviews a third of them checked.

A PMM on r/ProductMarketing described the off-site problem from the inside. Their company repositioned and AI kept citing the old messaging, and fixing it meant updating their own pages, working with influencers, writing bottom-of-funnel content, and getting information corrected on other people’s websites.

Soo… ask the assistants the questions your buyers ask, check whether the answer is accurate and current and which competitors show up beside you, and then spend your fixing time on the pages they send people to next, starting with your reviews.

Worth Your Time

  • Anthropic’s S-1, metric by metric (Tom Tunguz): the filing reports net revenue retention of approximately 900% as of September 30, on first-half 2026 revenue of $16.3 billion, and Tunguz notes nearly half of revenue flows through cloud marketplaces. That second number deserves more attention from anyone selling into enterprises, because it says buyers will happily spend through the procurement channel they already have.
  • Put your first AI agent on the contact form (SaaStr): Jason Lemkin says SaaStr’s Qualified-built agent booked 614 qualified meetings, and in one month 71% of closed-won sponsorship deals came from AI-qualified inbound, against a historic 29% to 34%. (The headline says $2M+ closed while the body says $1M+, so I’d go with the body.) The detail I’d act on is that the old form left about 1,000 sponsor leads with no human reply at all, so check how many of yours are sitting unanswered before you shop for an agent.
  • AI in UX: work is faster, feelings are mixed (Nielsen Norman Group): 521 UX practitioners rated AI’s effect on task time 4.2 out of 5 but their feelings about it only 3.57, and many said their companies required and tracked AI use, which led to performative use. If your team reports AI adoption as a usage count, this is a good reason to switch to track outcomes over metrics.
  • What 1,100+ marketing job posts ask for (MKT1): Emily Kramer found 47% of posts at 345 B2B startups ask for AI skills, but only 15% ask for someone who can build AI workflows or agents. If you’re hiring, that gap is your chance to write the job description everybody else isn’t, and if you’re looking, it’s the skill I’d lead with.
  • Price format can lift sales without changing the price (AMA): in a Journal of Marketing Research field test with a grocer, showing sub-pound items with a per-unit price instead of a per-weight one raised their sales 12% to 24% at the same price, because shoppers anchor on the smaller number. It’s a grocery study, but it’s a cheap reminder to test how a price is displayed before you test the price itself.
  • Salesforce’s $5.66 billion Braze deal (Digiday): the deal was announced October 20 and still needs regulatory and shareholder approval, and the worry Digiday heard from marketers is lock-in. If Braze runs your lifecycle program, I’d document where your journey logic and decisioning live now, while switching is still a choice you get to make.
  • Are we releasing anything original? (r/ProductMarketing): a PMM says their team’s latest prototypes are all copycat features, built with AI by looking at competitor websites, and the go-to-market plans are as dull as you’d expect. Over on r/SaaS, a solo developer says a near-identical demo of their new feature showed up 27 hours after they posted theirs, which is a decent hint at how long a feature-led launch story lasts now.

← All editions of The Growth Brief